Mickey Rooney (1981) • Anthony Andrews (1982) • Richard Chamberlain (1983) • Ted Danson (1984) • Dustin Hoffman (1985) • James Woods (1986) • Randy Quaid (1987) • Michael Caine / Stacy Keach (1988) • Robert Duvall (1989) • James Garner (1990) • Beau Bridges (1991) • Robert Duvall (1992) • James Garner (1993) • Raul Julia (1994) • Gary Sinise (1995) • Alan Rickman (1996) • Ving Rhames (1997) • Stanley Tucci (1998) • Jack Lemmon (1999) • Brian Dennehy (2000)
James Franco (2001) • Albert Finney (2002) • Al Pacino (2003) • Geoffrey Rush (2004) • Jonathan Rhys Meyers (2005) • Bill Nighy (2006) • Jim Broadbent (2007) • Paul Giamatti (2008) • Kevin Bacon (2009) • Al Pacino (2010) • Idris Elba (2011) • Kevin Costner (2012) • Michael Douglas (2013) • Billy Bob Thornton (2014) • Oscar Isaac (2015) • Tom Hiddleston (2016) • Ewan McGregor (2017) • Darren Criss (2018) • Russell Crowe (2019) • Mark Ruffalo (2020) • Michael Keaton (2021) • Evan Peters (2022) • Steven Yeun (2023)